Sweet Potato Casserole Recipe (2024)

Ratings

4

out of 5

3,267

user ratings

Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

mk

How far ahead can you bake the sweet potatoes? Thank you!

SpomerE

Can this be made ahead of time?

Bea

Why all the sugar? There is sugar in the orange juice and sweet potatoes are already sweet. I am going to make this without added sugar in the main part of the dish and half the amount of sugar recommended for the topping. Has anyone tried that yet?

Emily Weinstein

Hello all, apologies for the confusion about the eggs!

An earlier version of this recipe did in fact include eggs. We have since retested and revised it to make it creamier, omitting the eggs, increasing the melted butter and adding milk or cream. You'll see the corrected recipe here. We hope you'll find it even more delicious.

maeve

Comment:Leave out the sugarJuice the orange instead of using store-bought juice.Substitute coconut milk for the heavy creamFor the topping:-Omit sugar- Use some toasted coconut with the pecans.

Rosalind Hanckel

Yes, it can be made in advance... Just be careful reheating it so you don't burn the topping. Or better yet, make it in advance, but don't bake it with the topping until the last minute.

Barbara

I added orange zest, and a couple of tablespoons of bourbon and a few shakes of orange bitters. Unbelievably luscious!

RainCity

The size of the “casserole dish” needs to be stated!!! Is it a 9 x 13 inch casserole dish, or like the photo in the recipe indicates closer to 9 x 5 inch dish? VERY FRUSTRATING!!!

Loren

Cooked sweet potatoes in Instant Pot on High Pressure for 15 minutes. They were perfect!

e.masten

I made this a day ahead (casserole and its topping separately refrigerated) using the juice of half a Cara Cara orange. The next day, after brought to room temperature, I reheated it for 30 mins. at 350. It was light and creamy; accompanied an Easter ham; everyone loved it (especially the men).

John

Bea, how did your family like your reduced sugar version? Did you make any other changes? I usually put a little cinnamon & nutmeg in mine along with a shot of bourbon. The tiny amount of alcohol cooks off, so no problem there, and I like its flavor.

Debbie

At our house we try to make everyone happy...for the topping angle stripes of mini marshmallows and the pecan mixture alternately (idea from Southern Living.) It looks pretty and all get their favorite topping.

Marian Burros

EJL

Please someone respond to how far in advance this can be prepared.

Tessa

Looks to me like a 7" x 11", but you could use 9x9 or a round dish 10" across for about the same area. I do a similar praline sweet potato casserole -- which is delicious with the combination of creamy mashed sweet potatoes and crunchy toasted pecan topping -- using about 5-6 potatoes and baking it in a 9x13 dish.

Margaret

I substitute a tablespoon of maple syrup for the sugar in the potatoes. They are still plenty sweet and delicious.

Dean LP

Just did a variation on this recipe. Not wanting to use milk from a can (snob, snob) I substituted it with one part heavy cream and two parts whole milk. I'm sure it gave the dish more body and a richer flavor.

Jen

Too sweet and far too watery. I thought I would up my game with a new recipe, but this was an unexpected flop.

KYounginDallas

This was a hit at Thanksgiving 2023. Will be a regular potluck contribution for me annually! Thanks!

Sam Shepperd

This was very good and will go into my Thanksgiving recipe file. I added about a teaspoon of orange zest to complement. Don’t skip the topping.

Sharon

Made this in an 9" round casserole dish. I roasted the potatoes longer, about 2 hours -- they were sweet enough that I omitted the brown sugar in the potatoes completely and didn't miss it. Also swapped the cream for unsweetened soy milk and felt fine about that too. A big hit at Thanksgiving!

:)

Added cinnamon and vegan marshmallows on top

Martha M

A big hit with everyone. I reduced the brown sugar in the potatoes by 1/2, used 1 cup pecans

Jeanne

One of my favorite Thanksgiving traditions - love this recipe, love the dish. The only bad part was that I didn't have any leftovers - it went fast!

Robyn

I modified the topping. Added 1/3 c gf flour and 1/2 c oatmeal to pecans butter and sugar. Pinch of salt. My son in law who never liked sweet potato casserole before went wild for it.

Jay

“Bake the potatoes “: Does that mean just throw them in the oven (maybe pricking with) fork? Normally, a baked potato involves coating with an oil, wrapping in foil and then baking. I feel like not wrapping could produce dry potato flesh.

Martha M

I baked them with no coating or pricking and it was easy to peel the skin off, inside was still moist

David

Is there any reason NOT to do the initial baking of the potatoes in a microwave? So quick and doesn't take up oven space on Thanksgiving..

Mamie

Can you substitute walnuts or another nut for pecans? Having a hard time finding pecans the day before Thanksgiving.

Deirdre M.

You think I can get away with a 7"x11" dish? Just reduce everything a little?

CIndy

Yes, this recipe is very flexible!

Chris Semrod

Yummy. Add an ounce of tequila for a wonderfully flavored twist.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Sweet Potato Casserole Recipe (2024)

FAQs

How do you make a sweet potato casserole not runny? ›

Eggs and cream help stabilize the dish and prevent it from becoming too runny (a common complaint with many sweet potato casserole recipes). Make it as smooth or chunky as you like!

Why put egg in sweet potato casserole? ›

The egg is the all-important binder in a sweet potato casserole: it enriches and stiffens the mixture without making it heavy. Make sure to cool the mash slightly before adding the egg so it doesn't scramble, and to stir well so there are no streaks of cooked egg white in the finished dish.

What's the difference between sweet potato pie and sweet potato casserole? ›

The difference is that sweet potato casserole can either have a toasted marshmallow top or a crunchy brown sugar/nut top and is made with brown sugar in the casserole. Sweet potato pie is made with white sugar, has nothing on top, but can be served with whipped topping.

Why is my sweet potato still hard after baking? ›

The reason they are hard in the middle is cook them longer or on a higher temperature. Soaking will not help soften your sweet potato unless you are putting the potato and water in a pot on the stove and cooking it. If your sweet potato is still hard it's not cooked enough.

How do you make a casserole less runny? ›

Thicken a meat casserole the most popular way with flour.

Add some flour to your pan after you've browned the meat and before adding any liquid. This way, the flour will soak up the juices and fat in the pan. Add about one teaspoon of flour at a time until you get the right thickness.

How do you make a casserole less watery? ›

10 Tips To Fix Or Prevent Watery Casseroles
  1. Prep Vegetables Ahead Of Time. Vegetables boiling on a stove - Solstock/Getty Images. ...
  2. Add A Starch. ...
  3. Experiment With Pasta Or Grains. ...
  4. Take The Lid Off. ...
  5. Drain Fat From Meat. ...
  6. Choose A Dry Or Low-Fat Cheese. ...
  7. Sprinkle Seeds Into Your Bake. ...
  8. Remove Excess Liquid.
Oct 29, 2023

Why do you soak sweet potatoes before baking? ›

The cold water bath helps rinse the starch off the sweet potatoes so they're a bit more crispy.

How do you thicken a sweet potato casserole? ›

Add more potato and no liquid also you could use potato flakes to thicken them to the texture you like. Either with plain(all purpose) flour or cornflour mixed in milk to disolve first themn poured in ( not too much liquid just enough to disolve the powder).

Why do Americans put marshmallows on sweet potato casserole? ›

Most people point to a 1917 pamphlet by the Angelus Marshmallow Company as the first time sweet potatoes and marshmallows came together. This company is believed to be the first to commercially-produce and sell the squishy white marshmallows we know, roast, and snack on today.

How do you know when sweet potato casserole is done? ›

you should see it firm, but still paste like. Once it bulges and you start to see cracks, it will be overcooked. You don't need anything of those fancy gadgets for casserole! You can grab a potato masher or whisk and mash them up.

What variety of sweet potato is best for casserole? ›

Jewel. With copper skin and deep-orange flesh that's moist and tender when cooked, the jewel is a go-to potato for traditional baking and casseroles.

When should you not eat sweet potatoes? ›

How to tell if sweet potatoes have gone bad. If your sweet potato is soft in spots, smells rotten, or oozes a mysterious liquid, that potato should be discarded. Another sign that sweet potatoes have taken a turn for the worse is if they start growing stalky purplish sprouts.

Should you peel sweet potatoes before boiling? ›

There is not much difference between boiling sweet potatoes with the skins on versus peeling them, but you will get a boost of fiber and potassium if you keep the skin on. The skin also adds a subtle texture to each bite. If you're looking for a smoother mash, peel the potatoes first before boiling.

What is the sticky stuff coming out of my sweet potato? ›

Initially, it may be off-putting, but it's actually indicative of a healthy potato and a flavorful meal. FoodsGuy explains that this thick, white, sticky liquid is just a mixture of sugar and water from the sweet potato leaking a bit after getting excited by the prospect of being part of such a delicious meal.

How do you thicken up sweet potato casserole? ›

Choose orange sweet potatoes for the best flavor and sweetness. Brown sugar adds a depth of flavor with a hint of molasses and helps create a caramel-like sauce. All-purpose flour will help thicken the sauce and give some structure.

What do I do if my potato bake is too runny? ›

Try letting the dish rest for 10 minutes or so to let the water get absorbed and let the sauce thicken. Try cooking your recipe longer.

How do you thicken runny sweet potatoes? ›

You can use what you have on hand: Flour, cornstarch, or powdered milk are all solid options that are probably already in your pantry. For what it's worth, we recommend sticking with cornstarch—it has twice the thickening power of flour and it's safe for gluten-free diets.

Should sweet potato casserole be firm? ›

you should see it firm, but still paste like. Once it bulges and you start to see cracks, it will be overcooked. You don't need anything of those fancy gadgets for casserole! You can grab a potato masher or whisk and mash them up.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jonah Leffler

Last Updated:

Views: 5564

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jonah Leffler

Birthday: 1997-10-27

Address: 8987 Kieth Ports, Luettgenland, CT 54657-9808

Phone: +2611128251586

Job: Mining Supervisor

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Electronics, Amateur radio, Skiing, Cycling, Jogging, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Jonah Leffler, I am a determined, faithful, outstanding, inexpensive, cheerful, determined, smiling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.